This is one of my perspectives on Bitcoin, what do you all think?

I was in r/money discussing Bitcoin, and used this explanation to argue my point. I think it's a good thought experiment to explain the benefits of Bitcoin, but I haven't fully thought it through. Am I wrong, or could this be expanded upon? What are your opinions?

Here is the thread if you are interested further:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Money/s/mhTb68HPzJ